Search for a materials markup and you will get a percentage. Twenty percent, ten, thirty — stated with confidence, on pages that never say where the number came from: contractor blogs, supply-house content, a trade forum thread with eighty replies and fifteen different answers. Not one of the pages ranking for that question shows a dataset, a survey, or a single cost build-up. It is a number that has been copied around the trade for long enough to sound like a standard.
It also has the wrong shape. A percentage of the parts bill pays the same rate for a $40 part as for a $4,000 one — but the costs the markup exists to cover are per trip, not per dollar. Fetch a $40 part and a $4,000 part and you have made the same two journeys, burned the same hour, and paid the same card fee. Twenty percent of the first is eight dollars. Twenty percent of the second is eight hundred. One of those numbers is a business; the other is a rounding error with a receipt attached.
What follows is the version you can check: what your markup has to cover, how to find your own number from your own receipts, and the change-order line for the parts you find mid-job.
The receipt test: one job, line by line
Take one job that needed parts. The example here is a small plumbing job — two exterior hose bibs and a shutoff replaced.
Parts at cost (what you actually paid, not list price):
- two hose bibs at $28 — $56
- one shutoff — $19
- fittings and tape — $14
- total parts: $89
The trips the parts required, priced at your billable floor — $62.42 an hour in this example (how that number is built is in the pricing article):
- pickup, 40 minutes round trip — $41.61
- return for the wrong fitting, 35 minutes — $36.41
- total trips: $78.02
What the materials line actually cost you: $167.02 — $89 of parts plus $78.02 of your own hours spent fetching them.
What a 20% markup charged: $106.80. Of which the markup itself is $17.80.
So the 20% paid eighteen dollars toward seventy-eight dollars of trips. The materials line came up $60.22 short, on a job that otherwise looked fine, and the shortfall landed in the labor rate where you will never see it.
To recover $167.02 on $89 of parts, the multiplier has to be 1.88 — an 88% markup. That is what “20%” was standing in for, on this job, and it is why the copied number feels generous and behaves badly: it was never a percentage of the right thing.
One caveat before anyone reprints 88% as advice: it is this job’s number, not yours. A job that needs no second trip, or one where you carry the part on the van, has a different number. That is the point of doing the test on your own receipts rather than taking a figure from an article — including this one.
What the markup has to cover
A markup is not profit. It is the recovery of costs the parts bill does not show — and what is left after those is the profit. Seven costs, and none of them are a percentage of anything:
| What it pays for | How to measure it on your own jobs | This job |
|---|---|---|
| Pickup and return trips | minutes at the wheel × your floor rate | $78.02 |
| Returns and restocking | count last month’s returns; time each one cost you | the 35-minute return above |
| Card processing | the percentage on your processor statement, applied to the invoice | $3.10 on a $106.80 materials line |
| Stock you carry | stocktake difference and dead stock, divided by jobs per year | not in this job — parts were bought for it |
| Warranty callbacks | unpaid return visits × hours, last twelve months | none yet — and that is the risk |
| Rework you did not bill | return visits for your own mistakes, last quarter × hours at the floor rate | none in this job |
| Damage and waste | parts you could not return, last quarter | none in this job |
The trips are the big one because they are the one nobody counts. If you bill a trip charge openly, the markup can be smaller — but you cannot do neither and expect the materials line to hold. Two structures work:
- Stock-heavy work (plumbing, electrical, HVAC): a derived multiplier per parts category, because trips and returns scale with the parts you keep on the van.
- Bought-in work (a specialist part ordered for one job): cost plus an explicit trip or handling charge on the invoice. It is more honest, easier to defend in an argument, and it survives a $4,000 part that would otherwise carry an absurd markup.
The monthly check, in three lines
Once a month, from your own records, not from memory:
- Materials charged — the materials line, added up across the month’s invoices.
- Parts paid — what left your account for materials, from the statements.
- Trips cost — count the supply runs, multiply by the time each took, at your floor rate.
Then: materials charged − parts paid − trips cost = what the materials line actually earned.
An example month from the same business: $2,410 charged for materials, $1,620 paid for parts, and fourteen supply runs at forty minutes each — 560 minutes, which is 9.33 hours at the floor rate, or $582.59.
- $2,410 − $1,620 = $790, which looks like a 48.8% markup on parts
- $790 − $582.59 = $207.41, which is 8.6%
Same month, two very different stories. If you had budgeted on the first number, you spent the difference somewhere and never saw it leave. The three-line check takes ten minutes and it is the only thing in this article that has to be repeated.
The change order, for the parts you find mid-job
Every trade has the moment: the wall is open, the part is wrong, the code requires something the quote did not include. The money question is not whether to do it — it is whether it was priced before anyone touched it.
CHANGE ORDER — job [number], [date]
Added: [what is being added]
Why: [found on opening / requested / required to finish]
Parts: $[cost] (+ [%] handling, the rate you use for bought-in parts)
Labor: [n] hours at $[your rate] = $[amount]
Schedule effect: [none / adds a day / needs a return visit on [date]]
Price to you: $[total], on the same terms as the original quote
Approved by: ______________________ Date: __________
The sentence that goes with it, said on site before the work continues:
“That’s not in the quote — the fitting behind it is seized and it has to be replaced. It’s $140 in parts plus an hour, so just over $200. I can do it now while everything’s open, or leave it and quote it separately. Your call.”
Three things that sentence does. It separates “found” from “asked for”, so the client is not deciding whether you are upselling. It gives a number rather than a range, so the decision can be made once. And it makes “leave it” a real option, which is what keeps the trust when the answer is yes.
When the client supplies the materials
Common on small jobs and it changes the arithmetic rather than the principle: you are selling labor only, so the trips still cost you and the markup is gone. Two things to do before the first day.
Price the labor with the trips inside it, because there is no materials line to hide them in — and say so in the quote, in one line, so nobody discovers it later.
When materials are the whole job
Supply-only work is a different business wearing the same van. The margin is on the goods, so the numbers that matter are the ones a retailer watches: how long stock sits, how often it comes back, what the card fee costs on a large transaction, and what a special order does to your cash for six weeks before the client pays. The pricing article’s floor rate barely applies — this work does not consume your hours, it consumes your capital. If you do both, keep them apart in your own records, or the supply jobs will quietly look like the service jobs and be priced like them.
Four things not to do
- Do not use the markup to hide a low hourly rate. A generous markup on parts and an underpriced hour still loses money on a labor-heavy job. Fix the rate, then price the parts.
- Do not quote materials at cost and add the markup at invoice. It reads as a bait price, and it turns a pricing decision into a dispute about a number the client thought was agreed.
- Do not apply a published percentage you cannot explain. If a client asks why materials carry 30%, the answer “because that is standard” is the weakest sentence in the trade. “Because it covers the two trips, the returns and the card fee” ends the conversation.
- Do not skip the monthly check in a busy month. The busy month is when the trips multiply and the shortfall grows — and the one where nobody has ten minutes.
What to do this week
Take your last three jobs that needed parts. For each, write down the parts at cost, the trips those parts required, and what you charged for materials. You will have your own multiplier by the third one — and a defensible answer the next time a client asks why the part costs more than it does at the supply house.
Then put the terms in writing so the parts argument never becomes a payment argument: the four emails that chase an overdue invoice.
—
Sources and check dates
No external statistics are used in this article, deliberately. Every figure is arithmetic on an illustrative job — $89 of parts, two trips at a $62.42 floor rate, a $106.80 materials charge, and a $2,410 example month — and is labeled as an example. The “20%” and “30%” claims it argues against are reported as claims, not adopted as figures, and no national or industry average markup is asserted anywhere in this piece, because no source was found that publishes one with a method behind it. If a later revision adds a market figure, it needs a named dataset and a check date on the page, or it comes out.
Related: how to price a job so the week pays for itself.
—